Advertisement

Top Rated - Accommodation in Sicily

When you look for accommodation in Sicily, there’s no better guide than the voices of those who have actually stayed there. The places listed as top rated here aren’t based on fancy editorial picks but on solid traveller reviews , plenty of them, not just a handful of five-star ratings from one-off visitors.

These accommodations perform well across the board for comfort, location, and style, often showing consistent praise in spots like Taormina’s historic centre or Palermo’s Kalsa district. You’ll find options that suit the warm, busy summer months as well as quieter stays in the shoulder seasons when Sicily can feel more relaxed. One tip? For a truly local experience with great reviews, try staying in Ortigia, Syracuse, where many spots combine charm with easy access to seafood markets and sunset strolls along the water.

The ratings you see come from real travellers , the ones who have explored Sicily’s streets, sampled its food, and then shared honest impressions of where they rested their heads. That’s why these recommendations matter and can help you pick your place with confidence.
Part of the My Guide Network Since 2006 180+ destinations
Search by Map

Book Top Experiences and Tours in Sicily:

If you're booking your trip to Sicily last minute, we have you covered. Below are some of the top tours and experiences.

View All Experiences

Local accommodation insight

If you're planning a stay in Sicily and want a reliably top rated experience, consider staying in Ortigia, Syracuse, especially outside peak summer months. This small island neighbourhood combines historic charm with close proximity to markets and eateries loved by locals and visitors alike. Many accommodations here get rave reviews for their atmosphere and genuine service. Another tip: book early if you’re traveling in October or April, these shoulder seasons offer mild weather and fewer tourists, allowing you to fully enjoy these top places without the summer rush. It’s a great time to explore Sicily’s natural beauty by day and relax in well-reviewed lodgings come evening.

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to common questions about Sicily’s top rated accommodation choices.

These accommodations all have a high volume of genuine traveller reviews with consistently strong ratings. The scores come from real visitors who’ve actually stayed there, not just one-off five-star ratings.

Many top rated places do well year-round, but some get extra busy or more expensive during July and August. Checking reviews from summer stays can give you a clear idea if a place handles the season well.

Absolutely. While cities like Palermo and Catania have many top rated options, smaller towns like Ragusa or Modica also have places with excellent reviews, especially if you enjoy a quieter, more local feel.

Both have their pros. Tourist centres tend to offer convenience to sights and nightlife, but local neighbourhoods like Palermo’s Kalsa or Ortigia in Syracuse often provide more authentic vibes and still have top rated accommodation.

Yes. Traveller reviews often mention cleanliness and safety, so accommodations with excellent ratings almost always score well on those important factors.

Yes, though top rated doesn’t always mean expensive. You’ll find guesthouses and family-run B&Bs with strong traveller praise that offer great value without compromising quality.

Explore Accommodation Categories

Hotel (41 places) Explore
Bed & Breakfast (25 places) At a Bed & Breakfast you'll not be treated as just another tourist but as a friend. Bed & Breakfast in Sicily does not always mean plain furnishings, on the contrary: many of them are lovingly decorated and equipped with antiques, or furnished in a clear modern-purist or maritime style. The colours range from warm… Explore
Farmstay (9 places) Explore
Resort (8 places) Explore
Aparthotel (2 places) Explore
Bed and Breakfast (2 places) Discover the charm of staying in a cozy bed and breakfast in Sicily, where you can enjoy a comfortable and personalized accommodation experience. Sicilian bed and breakfasts offer a warm and welcoming atmosphere, often run by friendly locals who are eager to share their love for the island. Wake up to a delicious… Explore
Campsite (2) •

Top Things To Do in Sicily

See All →

Top Things To Do in Sicily

Click to See All

Trusted local guides, read by millions every month

  • 2006 online since
  • 27.8M page views a month across the network
  • 14 languages

180+ destination guides, one network

Every guide covers a single destination on its own website, with events, restaurants, things to do and places to stay chosen from local recommendations.

My Guide Network Locations

Nearby Destinations

Also nearby: My Guide MacedoniaMy Guide AthensMy Guide French Riviera

See all destinations

Add to your trip
Day {[{day.day}]} {[{day.dateFormat}]}
MorningAfternoonEvening

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.

Add to day {[{trip.popover.day}]}Add to trip Cancel
Added to your trip Added to day {[{trip.toast.day}]}, MorningAfternoonEvening Saved to your trip Already in your trip Transfer saved to your trip Save your trip to get fresh suggestions Staying in {[{trip.toast.label}]} Base cleared Trip deleted Link copied Could not save your trip Something went wrong, please try again