Advertisement

Top Rated - Restaurants in Sicily

If you’re hunting for the highest rated restaurants in Sicily, this list is shaped by real visitors, not critics or editors. These spots have earned their stellar reputations through countless positive reviews from travellers who’ve genuinely enjoyed their food and atmosphere. Think strong ratings with enough feedback to back it up,no one-off five stars that feel suspect.

Some favourites are tucked away in historic neighbourhoods like Ortigia in Syracuse or Palermo’s Kalsa district, where locals and travellers alike rave about traditional Sicilian dishes. Season matters too,ask for fresh catch in summer or hearty dishes with seasonal produce in winter. One tip: try booking a couple of days ahead during the busy months, especially in Taormina or Cefalù, or you might just miss out on those top table experiences.
Part of the My Guide Network Since 2006 180+ destinations
Search by Map

Book Top Experiences and Tours in Sicily:

If you're booking your trip to Sicily last minute, we have you covered. Below are some of the top tours and experiences.

View All Experiences

Local tip for dining

If you find yourself in Palermo, head to the Ballarò market early in the day. It’s a great spot to sample authentic Sicilian street food that locals rave about before sitting down at a nearby highly rated trattoria for a proper meal. Also, be mindful that many top places close mid-afternoon for a few hours, especially outside the main tourist season. Plan around that to avoid disappointment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions travellers ask about Sicily’s top rated dining spots.

The places listed have consistently strong scores with plenty of reviews from travellers who’ve actually eaten there. These ratings aren’t based on just a handful of stars but reflect a broad range of opinions over time.

In popular towns like Palermo, Taormina, and Ortigia, it’s smart to book in advance, especially during peak tourist seasons. Locals also visit, so tables fill up quickly on weekends.

Yes, many do. You’ll find classic dishes like pasta alla Norma, fresh seafood, and arancini, all prepared with local ingredients and care, which is often what travellers praise the most.

Prices can vary widely even among top rated places. While some might be pricier due to location or ingredients, others offer excellent value without sacrificing quality.

Both have standout options. Coastal towns often excel at fresh seafood, while cities like Palermo and Catania offer vibrant street food and traditional trattorias with strong traveller reviews.

Many top rated restaurants accommodate vegetarian diners with hearty Sicilian dishes based on local vegetables, cheeses, and pasta. It’s always good to check the menu or ask ahead.

Explore Restaurants Categories

Regional & Local Sicilian Cuisine (157 places) Sicilian cuisine is a reflection of the island's rich history and diverse cultural influences. From the Greek, Arab, Norman, Spanish, and Italian civilizations that have occupied Sicily over the centuries, each has left a mark on the island's culinary traditions. Some of the key ingredients in Sicilian cuisine include… Explore
Seafood (131 places) Sicily, an island nestled in the Mediterranean Sea, is renowned for its delectable seafood cuisine. With its proximity to the sea, Sicilian seafood dishes are a highlight of the local culinary scene. From freshly caught fish to succulent shellfish, seafood in Sicily is a true gastronomic delight. The island's unique… Explore
Cafés, Gelaterias, Pastry Shops & Street Food (97 places) When it comes to culinary delights in Sicily, the vibrant scene of cafés, gelaterias, pastry shops, and street food vendors is a must-experience for any visitor. Cafés in Sicily offer a unique blend of Italian coffee culture with a touch of Sicilian flair, making them the perfect spots to sit back, relax, and enjoy a… Explore
Fine Dining (55 places) When it comes to Fine Dining in Sicily, you can expect a blend of traditional flavors and innovative techniques in a sophisticated setting. With influences from Greek, Arab, and Spanish cuisines, Sicilian fine dining establishments offer a unique gastronomic experience that showcases the island's rich history and… Explore
Italian (52 places) When it comes to Italian cuisine in Sicily, you're in for a treat. From traditional pasta dishes to fresh seafood options, the local restaurants here offer a truly authentic experience. Be sure to try arancini, a beloved Sicilian snack, at Antica Focacceria San Francesco in Palermo. And for a taste of the best cannoli… Explore
Pizza, Pizza (47 places) When it comes to pizza, Sicily is in a league of its own. The island’s unique culinary heritage has produced some of the most delicious and authentic pizzas you will ever taste. From the renowned Neapolitan-style pizza to the local specialties like sfincione and vastedda, Sicilian pizzas are a must-try for any food… Explore
Pizza (33) • Meaty Delights (28) • International Cuisine (26) • Budget Eateries (21) •

Top Things To Do in Sicily

See All →

Top Things To Do in Sicily

Click to See All

Trusted local guides, read by millions every month

  • 2006 online since
  • 27.8M page views a month across the network
  • 14 languages

180+ destination guides, one network

Every guide covers a single destination on its own website, with events, restaurants, things to do and places to stay chosen from local recommendations.

My Guide Network Locations

Nearby Destinations

Also nearby: My Guide MacedoniaMy Guide AthensMy Guide French Riviera

See all destinations

Add to your trip
Day {[{day.day}]} {[{day.dateFormat}]}
MorningAfternoonEvening

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.

Add to day {[{trip.popover.day}]}Add to trip Cancel
Added to your trip Added to day {[{trip.toast.day}]}, MorningAfternoonEvening Saved to your trip Already in your trip Transfer saved to your trip Save your trip to get fresh suggestions Staying in {[{trip.toast.label}]} Base cleared Trip deleted Link copied Could not save your trip Something went wrong, please try again